data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9440f/9440f6ec1b379c4e80f8df15e1609b5c86f64f10" alt=""
Over at ECW Finlay began being challenged by Mike Knox. Knox accused Finlay of being soft because Finlay would dance around with his son Hornswoggle and invite kids from the audience to dance in the ring. On the August 26 edition of ECW Finlay and Knox had a match with Finlay getting the victory and proving that though he is a family man he still is the man who loves to fight.
On September 7, 2008 Finlay competed in the ECW Scramble match at Unforgiven against the then ECW Champion Mark Henry, Miz, Matt Hardy and Chavo Guerrero. The match was won by Matt Hardy who became the new ECW Champion that night.
On November 11, 2008 on ECW Finlay would battle fellow face Matt Hardy for the ECW Championship. In a hard fought match Matt Hardy was able to defend his title after hitting the Twist of Fate on Finlay.
Finlay would battle Mark Henry December 14, 2008 at Armegeddon in a Belfast Brawl. With a little help from Hornswoggle and a shilaleigh, Finlay was able to get the win over the worlds strongest man.
On the February 3rd edition of ECW Finlay beat ECW champion Jack Swagger ending the match with a Celtic Cross and pin in non title match. Finlay became the first to beat Swagger since Swagger joined ECW.
This led up to a ECW Championship match for Finlay against Swagger on February 15, 2008 at No Way Out. Finlay was not able to get the win that night though as Jack Swagger would successfully defend his ECW title.
On April 5th, 2009 Finlay competed at Wrestlemania 25 in a 8 man Money in the Bank matchup. Unfortunately for Finlay he did not succeed in winning the match as CM Punk won the MITB match for the second year in a row.
In the 2009 Supplemental Draft, Finlay and Hornswoggle were separated when Hornswoggle was drafted to Raw.
In late May 2009, Finlay suffered a legitimate eye injury, sidelining him temporarily. He returned on June 16, attacking Christian, Tommy Dreamer and Jack Swagger.
At The Bash he participated in a Championship Scramble match for the ECW Championship, but was unsuccessful.
He was traded to the SmackDown brand on June 29, 2009. His first match returning to the brand was against Ricky Ortiz which Finlay won.
Some Finlay Facts
Birth Name: David Edward Finlay
Birth Date: October 20, 1958
Nickname: The man who loves to fight
Height:6' ft 2 inch
Finishing Move:The celtic cross & using his weapon - the shillelagh
Has a wife and one son